This second prequel to The Hunger Games series is much closer to a traditional prequel than 2023's The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes - that was an origin story for the franchise's villain President Snow, whereas this hews closer to the originals. It's a hard life out in the fringes, there's the flickers of a rebellion, and there's a lot of teenagers being fed into a machine that only produces corpses.
For the extra special 50th Anniversary Hunger Games, there's four tributes instead of the usual two to be collected. For Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zida), it's also his birthday. As seemingly the most popular young man in his rural village (District 12's location is never specified, but they make moonshine and Haymitch has a southern twang in his voice), it's a day to check in with pretty much everyone before the televised ceremony where the four youthful contestants in the Hunger Games are selected.
Things don't exactly go smoothly - lesson one: reality rarely matches what the regime puts out on television - and Haymitch is torn from his loving family and girlfriend Lenore (Whitney Peak) to be sent to the Capitol. His fellow tributes are either obvious victims or, in the case of Maysilee (McKenna Grace), despise him; it'd be nice to think he's going to make friends in the big city but that ain't gonna happen.
It's clear the media production around this year's Games sees the District 12 crew as the dregs. Smarmy host Caesar Flickerman (Kieran Culkin) gets a few decent jokes in; producer Plutarch Heavensbee (Jesse Plemons) takes an interest for reasons of his own. And when things go wrong yet again during their big introduction, Haymitch makes a foe of President Snow (Ralph Fiennes). No wonder everyone keeps telling him he's going to die.
This ticks all the expected boxes for a deathsport movie. There are fights and people being killed by various traps and tricks - the Hunger Games are held in what seems to be an idyllic, almost Disney-like valley filled with flowers, butterflies, bunnies and deer, all of which are more deadly than they seem - and that side of things works perfectly well.
The real drama here starts when it becomes clear that while Haymitch might be the central character here, no matter what fights he wins or acts of rebellion he pulls off, he's not going to be the hero. There is a system around him that's bigger and older and much more cunning and ruthless than him, and it's going to give him just enough rope to do what is required.
The Hunger Games themselves are grim and this doesn't sky away from their brutality. What gives this film its bite is everything around them. The television production is basically an assembly line shuffling the kids to their graves; a running joke is that their production team can't be bothered and it takes a ring in (Elle Fanning, in a role later played by Elizabeth Banks) to give them decent outfits. The political system is built to crush everyone involved in one way or another, and it's always one step ahead.
This rarely hammers the prequel side of things home. There are a few "how are they going to connect the dots" moments with some characters, but the story here stands alone. And being a prequel allows it to go darker and deeper than you might expect; there might be a happy ending, but it's a long way off.
It's possible to see this installment as a step back, just a minor twist on the franchise's well-established formula. But it's also a story about rebellion that says fighting back is hard; the cost is high, progress is slow, and the system holds all the cards. This series might be well into its second decade, but it's more timely than ever.
- Anthony Morris






